Defining winter and summer in Boston
Weather
Boston
Keywords
Python
In the United States, one often hears people speak of the “official” start of seasons. Ironically, there seems to be nothing that is official about these dates. However, there is consensus about the dates. The “official” start of summer is the summer solstice (for 2024: 20 June in Boston, 21 December in Melbourne) and the “official” start of winter is (for 2024: 21 June in Melbourne, 21 December in Boston).
In Australia, the usual convention is to divide seasons by months. On this basis, winter starts on 1 June and summer starts on 1 December.
Is there a sense in which one approach is more correct than the other? Focusing on summer and winter, one definition for these seasons would be that winter starts on the first day of the 91-day period that is the coldest such period for a year averaged over a number of years. Similarly, summer should starts on the first day of the 91-day period that is the hottest such period for a year averaged over a number of years.
We answer this question focusing on Boston, USA (latitude of 42.3, longitude: -71.0).
Daily temperature data from Open-Meteo comprise a maximum and minimum temperature. So immediately we have two possible definitions of each season according to the temperature we use (e.g., summer could be the 91-day period that has the highest average minimum temperature or it could be the period that has the highest average maximum temperature. Here we consider both.
The start of winter based on the 91-day period with the lowest average maximum temperature is 07 December. The start of winter based on the 91-day period with the lowest average minimum temperature is 08 December.
The start of summer based on the 91-day period with the highest average maximum temperature is 16 June. The start of summer based on the 91-day period with the highest average minimum temperature is 17 June. So using either, we get close to the Australian convention for winter and close to the US convention for summer.
Interestingly, it seems that using average maximums for summer and winter gets closest to the current approach in Australia. However, even using these we have the issue that spring begins on 08 March and autumn begins on 15 September. This implies a spring of 100 days and an autumn of 83 days.